From
Home Brew, Henneberger learned that Lovecraft lived in Brooklyn, and he went to see him. "Meeting Lovecraft in Brooklyn was a rare experience," he wrote to
Sam Moskowitz, "despite the fact that he was weighted down with marriage problems. He was married to a beautiful White Russian girl, and it seems his work of reviewing and an occasional editing job did not provide the means to support her as she desired. The union was short lived. I tried in vain to get Lovecraft to come to Chicago, but he was tradition bound to New England, especially Rhode Island in which state I called on him a few months before his death. The first story I bought from Howard was 'The Rats in the Walls,' and I think it was one of his finest. However, I sat down with Howard and
Harry Houdini one evening while Houdini recounted an experience in Egypt or rather the Giza plateau. A few weeks later Howard submitted the manuscript 'Imprisoned with the Pharaohs.' It was published at my insistence, although Baird did not like it and Wright was not then at the helm of
Weird Tales. During this time I was publishing
College Humor and
The Magazine of Fun successfully... I never made any money with
Weird Tales, but the few headaches it caused were compensated by the association with men like
William Sprenger (business manager), Farnsworth Wright,
Frank Belknap Long, Seabury Quinn (who ran an undertakers' magazine) and many prominent men like
Harry Houdini who swore by the publication."
Subtitled "The Unique Magazine" and "a magazine of the bizarre and the unusual," the "early issues were undistinguished," according to
The Science Fiction Encyclopedia. After Baird's first 13 issues, a friend of Henneberger's, the songwriter
Otis Adelbert Kline (1891-1946), who had written
Weird Tales' first serial ("The Thing of a Thousand Shapes"), served briefly as editor (May-July 1924) on the issue planned as the last. "Problems with the printer," wrote Moskowitz, "more than lack of circulation, plunged the early
Weird Tales into debt. In order to pay it off, Henneberger sold his profitable
Detective Tales."
When the magazine reappeared (November 1924), it had both a new publisher, Popular Fiction Publishing Company, and a new editor, Farnsworth Wright (1888-1940). Born in San Francisco, the musicologist Wright had published an amateur magazine in high school, lived through the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and fought in the infantry during WWI before joining Baird as an editorial assistant, beginning with
Weird Tales' first issue. For the next 16 years, Wright, who suffered from Parkinson's disease, guided
Weird Tales through its peak years, although even at its peak,
Weird Tales had no more than 50,000 or so readers.
Between 1930 and 1934 Wright also edited
Weird Tales' companion magazine,
Oriental Stories (retitled
Magic Carpet in January 1933), and his love of Shakespeare prompted an edition of
A Midsummer Night's Dream with art by the
Weird Tales illustrator Virgil Finlay. Other
Weird Tales illustrators of the 1930s included
Margaret Brundage,
J. Allen St. John,
Frank Utpatel,
Vincent Napoli (who drew for DS Comics in the late 1940s) and
Harold De Lay (artist on 1940-47 comics for Novelty and other companies). Working with pastel chalks, Brundage created a series of controversial, erotic covers.
Wright discovered and nurtured a lengthy list of
Weird Tales writers – the poet
Leah Bodine Drake, the teenage
Tennessee Williams, film producer
Val Lewton (
Cat People),
Henry Kuttner, Robert Bloch,
August Derleth,
Nictzin Dyalhis,
Robert E. Howard,
Edmond Hamilton (who scripted for DC Comics from 1945 to 1966),
Manly Wade Wellman (who scripted for at least eight comics publishers between 1939 and 1951),
Catherine L. Moore,
Carl Jacobi, Frank Belknap Long,
E. Hoffman Price,
H. Warner Munn and
Donald Wandrei, while also attracting such authors as
Gaston Leroux (
Phantom of the Opera),
Gustave Meyrink (
The Golem),
Jack Williamson,
Murray Leinster,
E.F. Benson,
A. Merritt and
Algernon Blackwood.
Weird Tales first published
Robert E. Howard in 1925, and his Conan stories began in WT with "The Phoenix on the Sword" (1932). The 1960s revival of interest in Conan and other Howard characters led to numerous Howard-inspired Marvel Comics.
When Delaney purchased
Weird Tales in 1938, he followed the same procedure as he had with McIlwraith and
Short Stories, and Wright relocated in New York to continue as the
Weird Tales editor. The following summer, the 25-year-old Ray Bradbury showed Wright work by Hannes Bok, cover artist of Bradbury's fanzine,
Futuria Fantasia (1939-40). "Long before my appearance in Weird Tales," wrote Bradbury, "I had influenced its artistic makeup. In June 1939, I had traveled across the United States on a Greyhound bus, bringing with me a dozen or so Hannes Bok drawings and paintings. I visited Farnsworth Wright in his offices, and he immediately commissioned Bok to paint a cover for
Weird. I returned home on the bus in triumph, delighted that I had brought Bok and my favorite magazine together." The painting illustrated
David H. Keller's "Lords of the Ice" (December 1939), and other distinctive Bok covers fronted
Weird Tales until 1942. During the 1930s and 1940s, pulp magazine illustrators were usually paid between $50 to $75 for a cover painting.
The issue introducing Bok was one of Wright's last; he died in Jackson Heights, Queens, in June 1940. Delaney chose McIlwraith as Wright's successor, and she continued as
Weird Tales' editor for the next 14 years. Bloch had praise for McIlwraith's editorial abilities: "I met Dorothy McIlwraith only once, in late 1939. She seemed pleasant, but I recall little about her, and her letters of acceptance, together with those of associate Lamont Buchanan, don't linger in my memory. Actually, I think she's far too neglected. I can't dismiss anyone who published Bradbury,
Sturgeon,
Brown and other top talents. I think that she would have published more, had she been given the budget to compete with
Unknown Worlds, F&SF and other comparable markets. But that lousy one cent a word – and sometimes bimonthly publication – induced few writers to remain in
Weird Tales once better rates were obtainable elsewhere. I lasted longer than most, because I was always a bit stupid. (Still am, writing short stories today when I should be knocking out TV episodes at roughly 100 times the fee, plus an additional 100 times for reruns over the years.) But
Weird Tales was my first market, my favorite reading as a young fan, and I felt, and feel, that I owed it a lot."
Delaney and McIlwraith continued to fill the pages of
Weird Tales with Derleth, Bloch, Wellman, Hamilton and Quinn, while also introducing Leiber, Bradbury, the now-neglected female fantasist
Alison V. Harding,
Joseph Payne Brennan and others. In addition to Bok, other illustrators for the Delaney/McIlwraith issues included
Lee Brown Coye,
Matt Fox (who also illustrated for 1952-63 Marvel Comics and 1967-69 issues of
Castle of Frankenstein),
Charles A. Kennedy,
Boris Dolgov,
Fred Humiston,
Harold Rayner,
Henry del Campo,
A.R. Tilburne,
John Giunta (who illustrated many comic books from 1938 on),
Bill Wayne,
Jon Arfstrom and
Joseph Krucher.
Frank Gruber (1904-1969), who knocked out some 800,000 words for pulps in 1940, worked just as hard in 1941, but still found time to drop by for weekly chats with McIlwraith and Delaney, as he detailed in
The Pulp Jungle: "I don't think I missed an issue of
Short Stories that year. If I did not have a serial running in the magazine, I had a long novelette. Bill Delaney, the owner of
Short Stories, had become one of my best friends... On Mondays I always went into town... I made a call or two, then about eleven o'clock I would go to the offices of
Short Stories. Bill Delaney and I talked awhile, or played a rubber or two of gin rummy, had lunch and returned and played some more gin rummy. About four or four thirty I went home."
When Gruber went home it was to Scarsdale, but in January 1942 he moved to Manhasset, Long Island, where Bill Delaney lived with his wife
Margaret (whom he had married in 1923). The Delaney/Gruber friendship was interrupted when Gruber swung a Hollywood deal only weeks after moving to Manhasset. Delaney helped him make his exit. "We decided to close up the house, leave everything in it and take the train to Hollywood, carrying only our suitcases –- and Bob, who was then 22 months of age. I completed
The Gift Horse the day before we were due to leave. Bill Delaney came down to the train to see us off, and I gave him the last chapters and asked him to have them retyped and send the manuscript to Farrar & Rinehart. I wrote Farrar & Rinehart on the train. I told them I would be back in six weeks, that I needed a vacation. I did not see New York again until 1946."
In the midst of the 1950s wave of "weird" comics and competition from a new wave of magazines, such as
Galaxy Science Fiction and
The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, the
Weird Tales readership began to fall away. Following the death of Margaret Delaney in 1952,
Weird Tales was reduced to a digest-size format (September 1953), and then it closed up shop a few months later (March 1954).
In 1956, Bill Delaney married
Regina Cogan. He did not continue in publishing; one of his later business ventures was a Manhattan greeting card shop. After Regina Delaney's death in a 1970 auto accident, he took up residence in the New York Athletic Club. He died March 15 in Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts, after a long illness, survived by three children, 19 grandchildren and three great-grandchildren.
Complete runs of the 279 issues of
Weird Tales are highly valued by collectors, with complete runs being sold in the 1980s for prices between $20,000 and $25,000. After
Weird Tales folded in 1954, the word "weird" surfaced immediately on several short-lived 1955 publications – the British
Weird and Occult Library paperback magazine, the British pulp
Weird World and
True Weird. Edited by
Calvin Beck for publisher
Joe Weider,
True Weird later changed its name to
True Strange in order to kill a persistent office joke about
True Weider magazine.
All rights to
Weird Tales were next acquired by editor-publisher Leo Margulies. It was Margulies who gave
Mort Weisinger his first editorial job, earning $15 a week, at Standard (
Thrilling Wonder Stories). In the back of the hall during the First World Science Fiction Convention (1939), Margulies and Weisinger concocted the character of Captain Future, with Margulies plotting the magazine on the spot to the convention attendees. The following year the character debuted in both magazine form (
Captain Future) and comics (
Startling Stories, America's Best). Margulies was also instrumental in Weisinger's switch to DC as Superman editor-writer, advising him that pulps had less of a future than comics. "On the honor roll of great fiction magazines of all time,
Weird Tales rates very high," wrote Margulies. "Among devotees of the weird, fantastic, science fiction and off-trail, the magazine was considered a classic." With the backlog of
Weird Tales material, Margulies packaged two Pyramid anthologies --
Weird Tales (1964) and
Worlds of Weird (1965).
On November 14, 1969,
Weird Tales founder Jacob Clark Henneberger died. The legendary magazine Henneberger created reappeared in time for its 50th anniversary when Margulies revived
Weird Tales for four pulp-sized issues (1973-74), edited by Sam Moscowitz. After Margulies died in 1975, the
WT logo and title rights were acquired by
Robert Weinberg, editor of
WT50 (1974) and
The Weird Tales Story (1977). In the UK,
Peter Haining edited two
Weird Tales collections for Sphere in 1978.
In 1981, Zebra Books presented
WT as a new "paperback magazine" series, four issues edited by Lin Carter.
Brian Forbes' Bellerophon Network brought the magazine back for two issues in 1984 and 1985.
George H. Scithers revived the title in 1988 for the Terminus Publishing Company with assistant editors
Darrell Schweitzer and
John Gregory Bettancourt. In 1991, Schweitzer took full editorship, but the license to use the
Weird Tales title was revoked with the Spring 1994, and the magazine changed its name to
Worlds of Fantasy & Horror. The
Weird Tales title was licensed to DNA Publications, the publisher of
Absolute Magnitude and
Dreams of Decadence, in March 1998.
Robert Bloch, who fashioned almost half a million words for
Weird Tales (spread over 70 stories), once wrote: "Throughout the years, working with or for
Weird Tales was largely a labor of love for all concerned. The magazine was never a moneymaker; it attracted few advertisers, and its rates of payment to contributors was low, even by Depression standards. Yet, in a strange sort of way, it was probably the Depression of the Thirties which enabled the magazine to continue. Today's publishers and distributors would never bother with such a trivial source of revenue; today's printing houses would hardly continue a magazine which went so consistently into the red on so small a circulation; today's writers couldn't afford to aim their output directly at so non-lucrative an outlet for their work. That
Weird Tales managed to survive as long as it did is probably the weirdest tale of all."